01
Choose one question and retain the source context
Start with a question narrow enough to compare, such as who proposed the first shared planting day. Give each source a stable identifier and record its title, author where available, date and location of the relevant passage. Keep a short quotation or accurate paraphrase beside those details, marking which it is. A general account of the garden’s purpose may not answer the specific question. Retaining the context prevents an interesting passage from becoming support for a claim it never made.
02
Compare claims without smoothing over differences
Place the accounts alongside one another and describe where they agree, differ or leave a gap. One might describe an early conversation while another records the first public invitation; those could concern different events rather than contradict each other. Keep that possibility as a reviewer note until the sources support it. Do not count repeated versions of the same account as independent confirmation. The comparison sheet should make each statement traceable and keep the team’s interpretation visibly separate from the material being compared.
03
Write a synthesis that preserves unresolved points
Draft a short account using the claims the team can attribute clearly. Where sources disagree, describe the disagreement or narrow the statement rather than selecting the more convenient version without explanation. Keep links or references back to the source sheet so a later editor can inspect the basis for the text. Add outstanding questions to a separate list with the material needed to address them. The result is an editable account with visible foundations, not a claim that every uncertainty about the garden’s history has been resolved.